Reviewer Guidelines

REVIEWER POLICY

Reviewers Guideline

Substantive review, confidentiality, conflicts, and absolute AI prohibition
Reviewers are entrusted with unpublished scholarly work. Their primary duty is to provide independent human scholarly judgement that is substantive, constructive, confidential, and ethically responsible.
Absolute prohibition on AI
Reviewers must not use generative AI or other AI systems to analyze, evaluate, summarize, score, translate for assessment, or draft peer-review comments on a submitted manuscript. Reviewers must not upload the manuscript, excerpts, tables, figures, supplementary files, or confidential editorial correspondence to an AI system. This prohibition protects confidentiality, intellectual property, and the human scholarly judgement required by the 2026 accreditation guidelines.

Before accepting a review

  • Accept only when the manuscript falls within your expertise and you can provide a substantive review within the requested time.
  • Disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest and decline when impartiality may reasonably be questioned.
  • Do not accept if you have a close recent collaboration, supervisory relationship, personal dispute, direct competitive interest, or other material relationship with an identifiable author or research group.
  • Treat the invitation and manuscript as confidential and do not delegate the review without prior editor approval.

What the review must assess

  • Clarity and significance of the research problem or question;
  • Originality and identifiable scholarly contribution;
  • Engagement with relevant and current scholarship;
  • Conceptual/theoretical coherence;
  • Appropriateness and transparency of methods or analytical approach;
  • Quality, sufficiency, and traceability of evidence or sources;
  • Logical relationship between evidence, analysis, findings, and conclusions;
  • Research ethics, consent, data integrity, and possible misconduct concerns;
  • Accuracy and relevance of citations without coercive or self-serving citation demands;
  • Fit with Islam Realitas and contribution to the study of Islam and society.

Substantive review standard

A satisfactory report must explain the manuscript's main strengths and weaknesses and provide actionable scholarly recommendations. Comments limited to spelling, grammar, formatting, layout, or citation style are insufficient as a peer review. Language suggestions may be added, but they cannot replace critical assessment of the content.

Constructive and respectful conduct

Reviewers must write in professional, evidence-based language and avoid personal, discriminatory, hostile, or humiliating comments. Requests for additional citations must be academically justified and must not be used to inflate the reviewer's own citations or those of associates. Reviewers must not contact authors directly.

Recommendation and confidentiality

The reviewer should provide a clear recommendation to the editor, supported by the report. Reviewer identity remains confidential under the double-anonymous model. Manuscripts and unpublished information must not be retained, shared, used for personal advantage, or discussed outside the authorized review process. Suspected misconduct should be reported confidentially to the editor with supporting detail; the reviewer should not investigate authors independently.

Governance basis: Permendiktisaintek No. 9 of 2026; Directorate General of Science and Technology Decision No. 374/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026; COPE Core Practices; and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (Version 5, 2026).