Complaints and Appeals

GOVERNANCE

Complaints and Appeals

Fair review of process concerns and contested editorial decisions
The journal provides a transparent route for complaints about journal conduct and appeals concerning editorial decisions while preserving independence and confidentiality.

What may be complained or appealed

Complaint
A concern about journal conduct, delay, communication, reviewer/editor behavior, ethics handling, website information, fees, conflicts, or another process issue.
Appeal
A reasoned request to reconsider an editorial decision because of a claimed material factual error, procedural irregularity, unmanaged conflict, or important evidence that was overlooked.

Procedure

  1. Submit the complaint or appeal through the journal's official contact channel, identify the manuscript/article, describe the issue clearly, and provide supporting evidence.
  2. The editorial office records the case and identifies an appropriate person who was not materially responsible for the disputed action whenever practicable.
  3. The journal acknowledges the matter and may request clarification or documents from the complainant, editors, reviewers, authors, or Publisher.
  4. The matter is assessed against published journal policy, the editorial record, and relevant ethical standards.
  5. A written outcome is provided with the basis of the decision and any corrective action. Where the complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, it should be escalated to an independent senior editorial representative or the Publisher/Rumah Jurnal.
  6. If unresolved publication-integrity issues require institutional authority, the journal may refer the matter to the relevant institution, funder, ethics body, or other competent organization.

Appeal limits

An appeal is not automatically a new round of peer review and disagreement with reviewer opinion alone is insufficient. The appeal must identify a substantive error or process problem. Frivolous, repetitive, abusive, or threatening correspondence may be closed after a documented response.

Non-retaliation

Good-faith complaints and appeals are handled without retaliation. Individuals involved must disclose relevant conflicts, and confidential information is protected to the extent reasonably possible.

Governance basis: Permendiktisaintek No. 9 of 2026; Directorate General of Science and Technology Decision No. 374/DST/D.D1/HM.01.01/2026; COPE Core Practices; and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (Version 5, 2026).