ADDITIONAL MENU
Author Guidelines
JURNAL EDUCATIVE • INFORMATION FOR AUTHORS
Author Guidelines
Journal of Educational Studies | Research quality, transparent reporting and publication integrity
Jurnal Educative: Journal of Educational Studies exclusively publishes original research articles reporting novel, methodologically rigorous empirical investigations of learning, teaching, education policy, and educational transformation. Authors are expected to demonstrate a clear educational research problem, a substantive contribution to scholarship, and transparent reporting of research methods and findings. All submissions must comply with the journal’s focus and scope, manuscript template, and publication ethics policies.
Mandatory submission standards
Article category Original research articles only, supported by identifiable empirical data and a transparent research method.
Language English throughout the manuscript and submission metadata.
Recent literature At least 40 verifiable references published within the five years preceding submission. Older seminal works may be added separately.
International journal sources At least 80% of all reference-list entries must be articles from reputable international peer-reviewed journals.
Citation style APA 7th edition for all in-text citations and reference-list entries; DOI links must be verified.
The requirements above are EDUCATIVE editorial standards. Compliance with numerical thresholds does not replace evaluation of the relevance, originality, and quality of the cited literature.
01Journal Focus and Eligible Manuscripts
EDUCATIVE accepts original empirical research articles only. Each manuscript must investigate a well-defined educational problem, present the authors’ original analysis of appropriately collected or legitimately accessed data, and make a defensible contribution to educational scholarship or practice. A research article may investigate learning innovation, teaching and curriculum, educational technology, teacher development, assessment, learner diversity, inclusion, or education policy, provided its contribution lies within the journal’s published focus and scope.
- Quantitative original research: experimental, quasi-experimental, survey, correlational, longitudinal, or other valid empirical designs with appropriate data analysis.
- Qualitative original research: case studies, ethnographic, phenomenological, interview-based, observational, or other qualitative inquiries that report systematic analysis of original evidence.
- Mixed-methods original research: studies integrating quantitative and qualitative datasets to address a substantive educational question.
- Design-based or development research: investigations that report an original educational intervention, model, instrument, or learning resource together with methodologically appropriate implementation and evaluation evidence.
- Original secondary-data research: new empirical analyses of existing datasets, where provenance, permissions, analytical originality, and methodological limitations are disclosed.
The journal does not accept literature-only manuscripts, standalone conceptual essays, commentaries, or descriptive activity reports that do not present an original empirical investigation. Articles concerning a particular school subject or educational context are eligible when their findings make a meaningful contribution to teaching, learning, assessment, professional development, or educational transformation.
02Language, Originality and Exclusive Submission
- English is mandatory for the full text, title, abstract, keywords, tables, figures, captions, supplementary explanations, and submission metadata. Authors should ensure clear, precise and grammatically sound academic English.
- The submitted work must be original, not previously published in substantially the same form, and not under consideration by another journal.
- Any prior dissemination (e.g., preprint, thesis, conference version, or working paper) must be disclosed in the cover letter for editorial assessment; such disclosure does not by itself determine eligibility.
- Authors must not engage in plagiarism, fabricated data, falsification, duplicate submission, inappropriate text recycling, or citation manipulation.
Authors are responsible for the accuracy and integrity of all content, including material revised or translated with professional or AI-assisted language tools.
03Manuscript File, Research Title, Abstract and Keywords
Manuscript file and author information
- File and template: submit an editable Microsoft Word file (.docx preferred) prepared using the current journal template. Where an outdated template conflicts with these guidelines, follow the journal’s most recent editorial instructions, including APA 7.
- Author information: enter complete names, institution, city, country, e-mail address, corresponding author, and ORCID iDs where available in OJS metadata or a separate title-page file.
- Anonymous review: remove author names, identifiable acknowledgments, self-identifying statements, and document author properties from the manuscript submitted for double-blind review.
Research title: essential principles and recommended patterns
The title must be in English and no longer than 15 words. It should be concise, informative, discoverable, and faithful to the research design and actual focus. State the central educational phenomenon, key construct(s), intervention, or outcome, and add the population, educational level, or setting where that information meaningfully distinguishes the study. Use specific scholarly terms likely to be searched by readers; place the main subject early in the title.
- Construct or relationship + population/context: suitable for observational and correlational designs; describe an association without implying causation.
- Educational approach or intervention + learning outcome + context: suitable for intervention research; use causal language only when the design and evidence justify it.
- Educational experience or phenomenon + participant group/setting: suitable for qualitative inquiry; mention the methodological design only when it adds substantial clarity.
- Developed educational model or resource + intended purpose: suitable for design-based research with documented implementation and evaluation.
Avoid generic openings such as “A Study of…” or “An Analysis of…”, promotional terms such as “revolutionary” or “groundbreaking”, unverified novelty claims, unnecessary punctuation, obscure abbreviations, and conclusions that exceed the evidence. Capitalization must follow the journal template. A geographical name should appear only when it is essential to interpretation or transferability.
Illustrative research titles — examples, not existing articles
Formative Feedback and Mathematics Engagement among Rural Secondary School Students; Teachers’ Experiences of AI-Assisted Assessment in Indonesian Secondary Schools; Digital Learning Access and Engagement in Blended University Courses.
Abstract: required content and reporting standards
Provide a single-paragraph, unstructured abstract of 150–200 English words that can be understood independently of the full manuscript. The abstract must accurately report completed original research rather than intentions, proposals, or anticipated outcomes. Include the following elements in a logical sequence, without separate subheadings:
- Research context and gap: briefly identify the educational problem and the specific unresolved issue, limitation, or inconsistency in previous evidence that warrants the study.
- Purpose or research objective: state exactly what the study investigated or sought to determine.
- Methodology: name the research design and, where relevant, the setting, participants or dataset, sampling, data-collection instruments or procedures, and main analytical approach.
- Results: present the principal empirical results, including informative numerical estimates or statistical outcomes for quantitative studies and defensible themes or patterns for qualitative studies, as appropriate.
- Key finding or conclusion: explain what the results establish in direct relation to the research objective; distinguish the observed evidence from its interpretation.
- Original contribution: specify how the findings add to educational theory, empirical understanding, research methods, or knowledge of educational practice.
- Implications: provide one proportionate implication for teaching, learning, assessment, professional development, policy, or future research, as justified by the evidence.
Use concise, precise academic English and report substantive findings rather than general claims such as “the results are significant” without explaining what was found. Do not include citations, quotations, tables, undefined acronyms, invented precision, unsupported causal claims, or promotional language. The abstract must agree with the actual results, sample, analysis, conclusions, and limitations reported in the manuscript.
Keywords
Provide 3–5 English keywords or concise keyword phrases representing the main educational constructs, intervention or phenomenon, learner population, and relevant methodological or disciplinary context. Avoid repeating the complete article title, overly general terms, or uncommon abbreviations.
04Required Structure of a Research Article
The standard sequence below is recommended for original research. Section names may be adapted where justified by disciplinary conventions, research design or the current journal template.
- Introduction: establish the educational problem, relevant international research, the research gap, objectives or research questions, and the study’s contribution.
- Theoretical Framework or Literature Review (if appropriate): critically integrate relevant theory and prior evidence rather than listing studies without synthesis.
- Methods: specify the research design, setting, participants or data sources, selection and sampling, instruments, procedures, analysis, and ethical safeguards.
- Results: present findings systematically and transparently, with appropriate figures, tables, quotations, or statistical estimates.
- Discussion: interpret findings against the research questions, theoretical framework and previous studies; identify contributions, plausible alternative explanations and limitations.
- Conclusion: answer the research questions, outline defensible implications and limitations, and suggest reasonable directions for future research.
- Declarations and References: include relevant ethical approval, consent, funding, competing interests, author contributions, data availability, AI use and acknowledgments, followed by the APA 7 reference list.
All components of the article must report and interpret the authors’ original empirical investigation. Where the study design warrants a different sequence, authors must retain sufficient methodological and analytical detail for independent scholarly assessment.
05Research Design and Reporting Quality
Quantitative and intervention studies
Describe the sampling strategy and sample-size rationale, operational definitions, instruments and their validity or reliability, intervention or comparison conditions, analysis plan, missing-data treatment, and applicable assumptions. Present effect sizes and uncertainty measures when appropriate, rather than relying on p-values alone.
Qualitative and case-study research
Explain the research context, participant selection, data generation, analytic procedures, researcher positioning or reflexivity as relevant, and steps taken to support credibility, dependability and ethical interpretation. Quotations and field evidence must be traceable to the reported analysis while protecting participant identities.
Mixed-methods and design-based research
Justify the integration of qualitative and quantitative evidence or the iterative design process. Explain how the stages, instruments, implementation and evaluation support the claimed contribution and what remains untested.
For transparent reporting, authors are encouraged to consult the applicable APA Journal Article Reporting Standards (JARS) for quantitative, qualitative, or mixed-methods research, while following the journal’s article structure and reporting requirements.
Original secondary-data and longitudinal research
Identify the provenance, coverage, time frame, accessibility, permissions, and limitations of any dataset analyzed. Describe data preparation, inclusion criteria, analytic models or coding procedures, the management of missing data where relevant, and how the analysis generates new empirical findings. Longitudinal designs should address timing, attrition, and appropriate limits on causal interpretation.
06Reference Quantity, Recency and Journal Quality
Reference rules — all must be satisfied
(a) At least 40 relevant, verifiable sources dated within the five-year period immediately preceding the submission date; (b) at least 80% of every entry in the full reference list must be a peer-reviewed article from a reputable international journal; and (c) all sources must be accurately cited and directly relevant to the manuscript.
The five-year period is calculated relative to the date of initial submission, rather than a fixed calendar-year range. Foundational theoretical or methodological publications older than five years may be cited when essential, but they are supplementary and do not count toward the minimum of 40 recent sources.
For the 80% criterion, the denominator is the entire reference list. For example, a manuscript containing 40 references must include at least 32 articles from reputable international peer-reviewed journals; with 50 references, at least 40 must qualify. Reputable sources are assessed for credible editorial and peer-review practices, international scholarly relevance and verifiable indexing, ordinarily including Scopus or Web of Science, rather than on a journal title or publisher claim alone.
Prioritize high-quality primary research and current evidence. Relevant books, policy documents, validated instruments and foundational works may be included within the remaining portion of the list. Do not insert unrelated references merely to meet numerical targets or inflate citations to a particular journal, editor, author or institution.
07APA 7th Edition Citation and Reference Style
- Use the author–date system for in-text citations: for example, (Ibrahim Ahmed, 2026) or Ibrahim Ahmed (2026). For three or more authors, use the first author’s surname followed by et al. as prescribed by APA 7.
- Arrange the reference list alphabetically by the surname of the first author. Use sentence case for article titles and the prescribed italics for journal titles and volume numbers.
- Provide an accurate DOI in the form https://doi.org/... whenever a DOI has been assigned. Verify that each DOI resolves to the cited publication; do not duplicate the DOI prefix.
- Every in-text citation must have a matching reference entry and vice versa. Confirm author names, publication years, titles, volume, issue, pages or article numbers, and DOI metadata.
- Use a reference manager such as Zotero, Mendeley or EndNote, but manually audit imported metadata and APA 7 output before submission.
APA 7 illustration — an article published in EDUCATIVE
Ibrahim Ahmed, I. (2026). Enhancing philosophical concept acquisition through the 5E learning cycle model. Jurnal Educative: Journal of Educational Studies, 11(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.30983/educative.v11i1.11334
The example illustrates formatting only. Authors are not required to cite EDUCATIVE articles unless they are substantively relevant. Consult the official APA reference examples for additional source types.
08Tables, Figures and Supplementary Materials
- Present tables and figures with sequential numbering, descriptive captions, legible labels and source attribution where appropriate; refer to each item in the text.
- Use original or appropriately licensed visual material. Secure permission for reproduced content where required and disclose adaptations.
- Explain what the visualization demonstrates without duplicating all its contents in the prose. Avoid presenting the same findings unnecessarily in both a table and a figure.
- Provide relevant supporting instruments, protocols, codebooks, analytic code, anonymized data dictionaries, or other supplementary materials when these improve transparency and are ethically shareable.
09Research Ethics, Consent and Participant Protection
Research involving human participants, particularly children, students or other vulnerable groups, must follow applicable ethical requirements. Provide the name of the ethics review body, approval number and date where approval was required, or explain the applicable exemption. Authors must document appropriate informed consent and, where applicable, parental or guardian permission.
Protect personal information, confidential educational records and participant identities. Report data collection and use transparently, obtain permission for identifiable photographs or quotations where necessary, and respect institutional and legal requirements. Ethical approval is not replaced by a statement that an educational intervention was routine.
10Authorship, Funding and Competing Interests
- List as authors only individuals who made genuine scholarly contributions and who have approved the submitted version and accepted responsibility for their contributions.
- Disclose author contributions using a recognized contribution taxonomy (such as CRediT) where the journal submission workflow permits.
- Declare all relevant financial and non-financial competing interests, or explicitly state that none exist.
- Identify funding bodies and grant numbers where applicable; describe any role of sponsors in research design, data analysis, interpretation and publication decisions.
- Acknowledge contributors who do not meet authorship criteria with their permission. Authorship changes after submission require explanation and agreement of all affected authors, subject to editorial review.
11Artificial Intelligence and Research Integrity
- AI systems or automated writing tools must not be credited as authors; human authors remain fully accountable for all research claims, evidence, citations and submitted material.
- Disclose substantive AI-assisted activities, including generating or substantially revising prose, creating visuals, processing data or conducting analysis. Specify the tool, purpose, scope of use and human verification in the Methods, Acknowledgments or a dedicated declaration as applicable.
- Do not present fabricated AI-generated data, quotations, references, images or analytical results as authentic research evidence. Check all machine-suggested references against original publications.
- The journal may use similarity or AI-screening services as preliminary indicators, but automated scores alone do not conclusively establish misconduct. Editorial decisions require contextual assessment and fair consideration of author explanations.
A similarity report is required under the journal’s existing OJS submission checklist, which sets a maximum similarity index of 20%. This numerical threshold is an initial screening measure, not a substitute for an editorial assessment of attribution, overlap, text recycling or research integrity.
12Data Availability and Reproducibility
Authors should include an appropriate data-availability statement indicating whether data, instruments, analysis scripts or supporting materials can be accessed and, if so, how. Where sharing is restricted by confidentiality, participant consent, institutional requirements or law, explain the restriction and any responsible access process.
Methods must be described sufficiently for assessment and, where feasible, replication or analytical verification. Do not share identifiable student records or restricted institutional data without authorization.
13Editorial Screening and Peer Review
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial assessment for eligibility as original empirical research, alignment with the journal’s focus and scope, completeness, methodological quality, reporting transparency, English-language presentation, APA 7 compliance, and reference requirements. Manuscripts without a verifiable original empirical contribution may be declined before external review.
Manuscripts meeting the initial criteria may proceed to the journal’s double-blind peer-review process. The journal’s published ethics statement indicates that manuscripts considered for publication are reviewed by at least two subject specialists. Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, relevant reviewer assessments and journal policy, and may include revision, rejection or acceptance.
Authors must address reviewer and editor comments systematically and explain changes in a point-by-point response. Acceptance is not guaranteed by satisfactory formatting or payment of any publication fee.
14Submission Procedure and Required Documents
- Read the journal’s Focus and Scope, these guidelines, and the Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement.
- Prepare the editable manuscript using the journal’s template and the APA 7 instructions on this page, then produce an anonymized review file. The downloadable template must be checked for consistency before use.
- Register or sign in through the OJS Submissions page; enter complete and accurate author, affiliation, title, abstract and keyword metadata.
- Upload the manuscript and any declarations or supporting documents required by the current OJS checklist, including similarity screening and ethical approval where applicable.
- Check the final submission record and respond to editorial messages, revision requests and proof corrections through the official journal workflow.
Any article processing charges, waivers or payment conditions must be confirmed through the journal’s official published fee policy. Authors should not make payments to personal accounts or assume that payment influences editorial outcomes.
15Pre-Submission Checklist
- The manuscript is an original empirical research article with identifiable data and new analysis; it is unpublished and not under consideration elsewhere.
- The research makes a clear and defensible contribution to learning innovation or educational transformation.
- The entire manuscript and OJS metadata are in polished academic English.
- The specific, evidence-aligned title has no more than 15 words. The 150–200-word abstract reports the educational gap, objective, methodology, actual results, central finding, original contribution and justified implications; 3–5 keywords are supplied.
- The main review file is anonymized, with complete authorship information supplied separately.
- At least 40 references were published within the five years preceding submission.
- At least 80% of the complete reference list consists of articles from reputable international peer-reviewed journals.
- All in-text citations and references follow APA 7; DOI links and bibliographic details have been verified.
- Methods, results, limitations, required ethical statements, funding, competing interests, AI use and data availability are reported appropriately.
- The journal template, OJS submission checklist and applicable similarity-screening requirements have been met.
Further information and journal policies
Submission portal | Publication ethics | APA 7 reference guidance | COPE

